Imagine a carboard box in someone's driveway. It's sitting still when, suddenly, the wind picks up - it's a hurricane!
The carboard box flies off the driveway and into the air, where gravity takes over and pulls it back down.
When it goes back down, it doesn't just fall straight down, the wind still pushes it left and right.
The curve in the visual
I used quite a complex curve in the visual above:
It's actually quite difficult to create a curve like this, because it needs to satisfy a few conditions:
It must start at a given point and end at a given point.
It must look chaotic, but not too chaotic.
It must not go off the screen.
The initial point is and the final point is .
I made range from to to automatically satisfy the first condition in the -direction.
I added to make the final point correct.
Then, I just kept adding and subtracting terms until I got something that looked good.
Each term gets to make sure that at the boundaries they are , hence the curve still starts and ends at the correct points.
The force we are considering is gravity (ignore forces from the wind, just note that it affects the box's motion).
Recall that the work done due to a force is the dot product of the force and the distance moved:
(For a quick refresher on forces and work, see the appendix at the end of this page.)
However, we aren't just moving in a straight line - we are moving along a curve, due to the wind pushing the box around.
Instead, we can break the curve into small segments and sum the work done along each segment.
Let's call each segment , where is the segment number (starting from and going to ).
For each segment, the work done is:
So the total work done is just the sum of these segmented works:
In calculus, we take these discrete concepts and take limits to make them continuous.
As the segments get smaller and smaller, the work done becomes an infinitesimal work:
An infinitesimal change in the curve, can be written as:
Substituting this back into the equation for the infinitesimal work, we get:
Finally, the total work done along the curve is the integral of the infinitesimal work:
First, let's construct the parametric equation for motion along the circle.
For the counterclockwise direction, let's first start with a circle at the origin.
Let represent the angle from the positive -axis.
The height is given by and the width is given by .
Then, we can translate this circle to the center at . The parametric equation is then:
For the clockwise direction, we can just negate the -component:
To find the work done in the counterclockwise direction, we need to evaluate the integral:
Based on the definitions for the force and the curve, we can evaluate the force as:
And the derivative of the curve as:
Thus, the integral becomes:
We can evaluate the dot product and integrate to find the work done:
We can follow the same steps for the clockwise direction, but there's another way to do this.
Given that the clockwise direction is essentially just the negative of the counterclockwise direction, then the dot product would be negative.
To see this, take the infinitesimal vector and compare it to :
Therefore:
Meaning, the total work done in the clockwise direction is just the negative of the work done in the counterclockwise direction:
The difference in the work done in the two cases is .
The takeaway is that if you reverse the direction of the curve, the work done is the negative of the work done in the original direction.
When we talk about forces, we often talk about the work done by a force.
Imagine a force pushing on a ball, and the ball moves a distance (magnitude ).
Let's say the force is gravity - , and it is pushing on a ball of mass .
The work done is defined by the product of the force and the distance moved:
However! This is not the complete picture.
Gravity acts in the downward direction, but the ball is moving in a different direction:
In that case, the work done considers only the distance moved in the direction of the force, in this case, units:
This is otherwise known as the dot product of the force and the distance moved.
The complete formula for the work done in a straight line for a constant force is then: